WHY SOME PEOPLE QUIT KETO (AND WHY OTHERS STICK WITH IT)

Weight Loss Fluctuations (7.21.2025 to 7.27.2025)

Life is full of repetition and rhythm. From the cosmic surety that the spinning of the Earth will bring us a new dawn every day, to orange school buses recommencing their rumbling routes through the neighborhood in late Summer, to the hamper of dirty laundry that stays full no matter how often we wash, dry, and put away all the clothes. (Honestly, laundry is like the story of the fishes and the loaves!). Yes, we pass through our days, weeks, and years with constant, familiar experiences. Many of us can add another thing to the long list of lifelong cadences, those things which occur over and over: starting a diet—again. And again.

I've done it. I dare say you have as well. Over time, we have launched countless attempts to lose weight. Every time we're full of determination and resolve. "This time I will lose weight, get healthy, and eat 'clean' (whatever the heck that's supposed to mean). And, as predictable as the tides, we toss in the towel, wave the white flag, or otherwise rant at the Universe that it can "take this diet and shove it." Then rinse, lather, repeat. There will always be another Monday morning, right? Sunrise, sunset, high tide, low tide, dirty laundry, clean laundry, start a diet, ditch a diet.

Why do some of us continue the pattern of on-again and off-again so often? There are loads of excuses, all of which I used until they became threadbare self-justifications, with not so much as a hint of logic left to them. "Life came at me" (pray tell, what day does it not?) … "It's harder for me than other people. My metabolism is slow because of genetics."… "I don't have to weigh again until next Monday. That gives me six days to deal with these fries and a chocolate shake."

Yes, I employed twisted thinking that left me with a Gordian knot of rationalizations and an extra hundred pounds of body fat. I tried most of the diets and gimmicks that many people have. I juiced. I ate foods in specific combinations, ate grapefruit only, and remained meticulously low-fat, following the 'move more/eat less' guidance. There was the 'Summer of the Triathlons'; I tried drinking a gallon of water while only eating wheat germ with honey. (I never tried Weight Watchers because there was zero chance that I'd get on a scale in front of anyone.) However, I did try almost everything else, including low-carb diets. (I did the induction period of Atkins in college to lose those few extra pounds I gained in the first three semesters, and the ketogenic protocol is essentially the same thing.) I found success back then and went about my youthful endeavors, back in a size six. Things were different, though, after the birth of our second child. I put on a great deal of weight during the pregnancy and lost none after the baby arrived. That was the beginning of my whirligig of attempts to lose weight.

Start something/quit it. Start something else/quit it. Start/stop. Start/stop. There were several times when I revisited the low-carb diet. Then I would quit, caving to tortilla chips and self-delusion.

But this last time that I laid off the carbs—and the excuses—has been different. I've stayed with it and haven't needed to 'restart.' Not even close. Why has this time been different? There are so many foibles and variables to being human that it's impossible to pinpoint it down to one thing. I sense that, after three decades of trying to lose weight for cosmetic and vain reasons, I was motivated not to die. Or, at a minimum, not be miserable for the rest of my life. You, gentle reader, may recognize yourself in my experience. Perhaps you've had so many at-bats in the weight-loss/health-improvement game that you've worn out the pitchers, the relief pitchers, the back-up relief pitchers, and the ball-boys sent in to help out.

I had.

No matter the reasons why you might have tried before, only to strumble. When the time is right, assuming the protocol is a good fit for you, things will fall into place. We have control over what we put in our mouths. It's one of the few things in life over which we do have command. When we're ready to embrace that command, we can make food our bi…. uh … recognize that food is not the boss of us. (I can tend towards potty-mouth. Glad I caught myself!)

Why do some people quit keto and others stick with it? There are endless reasons for both situations. But it boils down to a very few because regardless of what other people's stories, each of us have our own. My story is one moments of happiness, frustration, achievements, embarrassment, dread, and triumph. Sometimes all in the same day. In that, I'm Everyperson. In my great fortune at having found me feet, and returned to the optimistic person I was before I started disappearing from my life, I'm what Everyperson can be. Can do. We can start. And we can stick.

If I can do this, you can do this. I promise.


Disclaimer: I’m not a medical doctor, researcher, or Ph.D., but instead, I’ve been fortunate to have had the time and resources to research the ketogenic diet, also known as LCHF (low carb/high fat). The information I share is based solely on my understanding of that research. We are all responsible for our own choices, including what we put in our mouths, and there’s no substitute for each of us checking things out ourselves. And I’m not a medical professional in any way. Go Keto With Casey is not a medical site. “Duh,” you might say. But best to make it clear to all. I welcome questions, comments, and even civil criticism. I’m still learning. So, if you have something to add, go for it. Links in this post and all others may direct you to affiliate links, where I will receive a small amount of the purchase price of any items you buy through those links. Thanks!